I'm not sure I actually have enough fic recced in this fandom that doesn't focus on Crowley and Aziraphale, but I really liked the idea of doing this grid format (set-up stolen from Doyle, and used by me in all of my major fandoms).
Straight-up list format available here.
And that mutual grooming thing that chimps do? Also good. If you see typos, broken links, or anything else that needs fixing on this site, please let me know. And always feel free to recommend me fanfic, books, whatever.